On the calories expended side, the clear winner is a power meter on a bicycle. The power meter measures actual power output and energy expenditure, which is easily and accurately converted to kCal.
For the indirect devices, it's a massive mixed bag with some very unexpected observations. Measuring galvanic skin response ended up being quite inaccurate. Garmin devices without a heart rate strap were insanely inaccurate, sometimes reporting 300% higher-than-actual calories expended. The best device has actually been the Apple Watch paired with an iPhone. The calories reported are usually within 5% of actual.
As for the devices claiming to track calories ingested, every device has been either outright fraudulent or, at best, vaporware.