There are huge inefficiencies in everything. That doesn't necessarily mean there's a problem. The only ones who think that hiring is a problem are those who haven't solved it.
Think of it as a bell curve (what a surprise). Some companies suck. Most are mediocre. But a few have it figured out.
I've been on both sides of this process more times than I can count and I've noticed that the companies that do it well have a lot in common:
- They rely on up front third party aptitude and personality screening to eliminate 95% to 98%. They pay, but it's a bargain.
- They use interview quantity (lots of them, by phone and in person).
- They use interview quality (peers, supervisors, customers getting well below the "surface").
- They use variety (interviews, testing, get-togethers).
- They check references without a canned checklist (logic path driven, in-depth).
- They use HR primarily for formalities.
- They take their time.
- They "solve a long term problem" for all parties involved.
I admire your desire to solve a problem that affects so many, but I wonder if your approach is the best way. Maybe it's better for the mediocre to do what already works by copying the excellent. Then they wouldn't have such a big problem to solve.