Rationally assessing risk and correctly assessing risk are not the same thing.Unless you have a time machine or are engaging in insider trading, rational risk assessment is the closest one can get to correct risk assessment.
Technical skill, time and effort also matter.
For some reason, you seem to think I'm claiming that arbitrary untrained women with no experience must outperform experienced male traders with graduate degrees on account of their womanness. I believe nothing of the kind. My claim is that other things being equal, women statistically make more rational risk assessments than men. Of course people in finance should have training and skill. If Wall St. were more committed to better risk management and the profitability that results, then perhaps it would do more to ensure that more women had the necessary training and skill sets; I understand that multi million dollar salaries are quite effective at motivating people.
To prove that hiring women would increase profits, you need to show that female traders would make more profits than male traders, not show that they are more rational.
We don't live in a world where there are lots of women in the upper echelons of the finance industry for comparison, so I can't show that. However, I can show you that all other things being equal, stock investors that are male exhibit overconfidence and trade more frequently than female investors. The net result is that female investors outperform male investors. As in, generate more profits. See http://faculty.gsm.ucdavis.edu/~bmbarber/Paper%20Folder/QJE%...
As for a PhD, most trading these days is quantitative.
As far as I know, most traders are not quants.
Also, why do you believe the financial crisis was caused by overconfidence, as opposed to an incorrect evaluation of the facts?
The two are closely related, are they not? Overconfident people tend to make incorrect evaluations: their confidence makes them ignore discrepancies that should be investigated. It also makes them shut out dissenting voices warning of future problems. Your question seems akin to asking "why do you believe the Challenger explosion was caused by a crappy design rather than the failure of an o-ring seal?".