Imagine, for example, if the oxygen concentration was increasing instead. Would you expect humans to multiply faster and reach a new equilibrium because of it?
Concentrations have indeed been much higher in the deep past. The concern isn't destroying all life, it's damaging or destroying civilization.
There are theoretical techniques for blocking solar heat. It remains to be seen how effective or practical they would be in the real world. There is a lot of potential for unintended consequences.