The java.util.Date API is pretty clearly modeled off of POSIX time, and therefore retains compatibility with POSIX's wrong decisions. I suspect that POSIX used 0-based months so they could index into some const char *monthNames[]; variable; since years and days are shown directly, there's no need to force them to be 0-based (not that day-of-week and day-of-year are 0-based as well).