Those are the one that come to mind when I think of simple and very powerful tools. There are many others. So I think Alan Kay and friends have demonstrated that we have made things complicated for dubious reasons.
But what has been built with these tools? If OMeta was really better, wouldn't we be using it to parse languages by now? They already have a successor Ohm, which is interesting, but I also think it falls short.
I'm searching desperately for a meta-language to describe my language, so I would use it if it were better.
I think they generally do the first 90%... but skip out on the remaining 90% (sic) you need to make something more generally useful and usable.
http://www.oilshell.org/blog/2016/12/27.html
I tend to agree and most of my shell is either written from scratch, or copying and adapting small piees of code that are known to work. I take ownership of them rather than using them as libraries.
That is even the case for the Python interpreter, which is the current subject of the blog.
I'm not quite sure, but I think OMeta falls even shorter than the typical piece of software. I'm not saying it's not worthwhile -- it seems like a good piece of research software and probably appropriate for their goals. But to say it generalizes is a different claim.
1) People just get started and get used to not really understanding the interface they are working with. Who hasn't felt like they were playing whack-a-mole with CSS layout? This means lack of conceptual clarity fails isn't notable.
2) Nobody ends up noticing just how complex the rules are.
It was 9 years from when I started looking for a tutorial like http://book.mixu.net/css/ to when I actually found it. That is...really quite bad.
In physics, we don't know what the fundamental rules are, we can only see complicated outcomes and have to infer (guess) what the rules might be.
In computing, we know what the fundamental rules are (universal computation; whether that's turing machines, lambda calculus, sk logic, etc. they're all equivalent in power), but we have to deduce what the complicated outcomes are.
In a limited way. Because we're making systems that involve people. Important and relevant aspects of human nature must go far deeper than our present understanding.