America’s once-thriving middle class is slowly fading away
marketwatch.com
marketwatch.com
In general it looks like the US has a wider-spread income distribution, but over time there's a trend to most of these countries spreading wider as well, which drives the reducing size of the middle income bracket. The exceptions to that reducing size look pretty heavily correlated with increased average income (Denmark, the Netherlands, France, Ireland and the UK).
That suggests to me that the original question ("What’s going on with America’s middle class?") is poorly framed to begin with; this doesn't back up the assertion that there is anything especially unusual going on with America's middle class, it appears to be more or less the same thing happening in many other countries.
What this article refers to as "middle class" in Britain would probably be referred to as "working class".
To confusing things further, in Britain referring to something or someone as a bit "middle class" would mean it was somewhat posh.
Eg Rich lawyer or doctor? Middle class.
CEO of a FTSE 100? Middle class.
...and if you really want to go down the rabbit hole, when we say "public school" we mean a very middle class group of private schools, such as Eton or Harrow.
Middle class is more the common professionals - managers, small business owners, doctors, lawyers, accountants, engineers, architects, academics, creatives. The marker used to be a degree or some success running a business, but the degree part has been devalued now.
Working class is everyone else. Even if they work in an office.
Put even more crudely the upper class creams off the money, the middle class keeps the money machine running, and the working class does the grunt work.
Income doesn't correlate neatly with these groups. It's possible - not even as an outlier - to be middle class and working in the arts with very little money, or be working class and earning six figures.
In my opinion, what's happened has been quite toxic. People have been given the illusion of social progress whilst true opportunity has been concentrated in a very small population. Those that want their country back have missed the point: it was never theirs in the first place.
http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/05/11/are-you-in-t...
"Based on your household income and the number of people in your household, you are in the middle income tier, along with 50% of adults in Raleigh. "
Following the article, however, you would be classified as 'high income'.
"...In inflation-adjusted dollars, the share of U.S. households making $100,000 or more has more than tripled between 1967 and 2017, from 8% to 26%, according to U.S. Census data, while the percentage of middle income ($35,000 to $100,000 a year) has fallen. "Something is not right.
Interesting reading, but a maddening lack of a definition for "disposable income".
Not really. The article goes into pretty good depth about its logic comparing them in pre-tax income (gross income) and after-tax (what it is calling "disposable income") across various countries.
http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/04/24/western-europe-middle-cl...
Thus, when gross income is used to define income tiers, the result is that higher shares of adults are estimated to be lower income or upper income, and smaller shares of adults are estimated to be middle income.
The chart here is telling, too: http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/04/24/western-europe-middle-cl...
Ross Perot, running as a 3rd party Presidential candidate in 1992, called it the "giant sucking sound" of US jobs going to Mexico due of NAFTA.[1]
Not long afterward, US trade with China drastically increased.[2] Then China was admitted into the WTO. And the rest, as they say, is history.
The manufacturing jobs lost during this period of time were, for the most part, middle class. With the loss of manufacturing, we've seen growth in minimum wage service jobs and growth in highly paid knowledge jobs (e.g. HN type people).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_sucking_sound [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_and_the_World_Trade_Orga...
"In inflation-adjusted dollars, the share of U.S. households making $100,000 or more has more than tripled between 1967 and 2017, from 8% to 26%, according to U.S. Census data, while the percentage of middle income ($35,000 to $100,000 a year) has fallen. However, lower income U.S. households ($35,000 or less per year) have only slightly fallen over the last four decades."
I found a chart on the interwebs that illustrates the point a little better. Check out the 2nd chart on this page, the chart titled "Real (Inflation adjusted) Average Household Income": https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/updates/2016/09/1...
What is shows is the bottom three quintiles have been stagnant in terms of income. Most of the growth has occurred in the top quintile and especially in the top 5%.
(a) Why do you think this matters for this metric?
(b) Aggregate into the EU.
> Odd results should be expected.
Why?
> If you looked at individual US States it would look much more like the rest of the cohort.
Citation needed.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U...
It's not your fault, but such writing which amounts to pairing black people with something bad, without explanation, is a 'dog whistle' for racists---silently letting them acknowledge each other without being overt.
No, it's not enough to say "but black people are poor, thus dragging us all down". One is supposed to not acknowledge race unless it is pertinent, so to many your example is akin to a tautology of "poor people are poor, America has more of them", after the mental erasure of the racially irrelevant text.
It's not as simple as poor people are poor. Making it more specific: Black people are poor in both the US and the UK [1]. The US has more black people than the UK. So, ignoring everything else, the US has more poor people than the UK.
[1] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/weekly-disposable...
PS. To those who think it's racist to say black people are poor, I'd say they're being elitist by assuming that being poor is bad or being labeled poor is derogatory.
http://www.theroot.com/hey-media-white-people-are-poor-too-1...