You seem to think this is a bad thing. Why?
You seem to think this is a bad thing. Why?
Sure, maybe we don't have free will but I still want to figure out how to build quantum computers.
That is if you believe in free will. I don't believe in free will (surely it's impossible) or determinism, but rather in chaos with (maybe) some reinforcement by deterministic systems (such as our brains). Our actions powered by constant rolls of the dice, at our birth, in our brains and on the surface of the sun where at this very moment photons are being released that indirectly animate all human life on earth.
TLDR of my opinions in this space: the cosmos is simultaneously deterministic and probabilistic. There is no free will. Nor are all things predetermined in the sense that most people use the word.
[1] -- https://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2014/08/08/laplaces-demon/
There is already unpredictability in all sufficiently complex formal systems. For instance, it's unpredictable whether Turing machine T(i) will halt. Determinism is all you need!
"Suppose that there is a device that can predict the future. Ask that device what you will do in the evening. Without loss of generality, consider that there are only two options: (1) watch TV or (2) listen to the radio. After the device gives a response, for example, (1) watch TV, you instead listen to the radio on purpose. The device would, therefore, be wrong. No matter what the device says, we are free to choose the other option. This implies that Laplace’s demon cannot exist."
This doesn't prove that the demon can't exist, just that it can't answer the question. If it knows what you will do in any case of its response, and it knows what its response will be, it knows what you will do, generally. It just can't tell you what you are going to do. Sort of a difference between being omniscient versus being omnipotent.
In other words, the demon knows that its response will be X, and your actions will be Y, it's response just can't be truthful. It's all still perfectly deterministic.
Free will is just a convenient illusion based on the fact that predicting the universe faster than realtime would almost certainly require more resources than the universe contains. At best, we can limit our scope for imperfect predictions based on imperfect knowledge and limited processing ability. The universe is likely deterministic, but there's no way to act on that in a meaningful way, so for the purposes of human existence, we may as well act as if we have free will.
Freewill goes beyond the concept of your brain deciding what to have for dinner.
People are actually analogous to some physical system it's much harder to predict the actions of an individual whilst predicting group actions on a larger scale is easier since the various individual inputs are effectively canceled out.
This is like modeling say a glass of water, modeling each individual molecule is nearly impossible because you get to the point of not being able to measure them especially when you trying to measure or predict the sub atomic make up of each molecule, but modeling the entire system is easy.
You are welcome to believe in God, orbital teapots, and/or free will, of course, so long as your belief doesn't lead to actions which create a negative imposition upon others. Sadly, that is all too common, and far less welcome, in my eyes.