On the other hand, a star quarterback or goalie has a disproportionate positive effect on the team's winning chances, and chances to win championships.
But even great quarterbacks struggle if the O-line is dysfunctional.
And you definitely wouldn't be better off with 6 star quarterbacks than 1 average quarterback and 5 O-line players.
The larger point is that individual stars definitely matter a lot in pro sports. And recruiting and retaining them with extremely disproportionate amounts of money doesn't seem to be irrational for most sports.