Oh, and his piece is littered with false comparisons (picking benchmarks post facto despite knowing he'd be compared to the S&P500 index total return) and falsehoods (international stocks, see VTIAX, have provided a positive return over the period he describes); hard to take him seriously at all.
Yes, hedge funds seek to hedge their bets against bear markets, but if you require two major crashes in 10 years to break even with passive investing, the smart money should go elsewhere.
He's spewing nonsense now because he got caught with his pants down. His livelihood depends on convincing people that "hedge funds" outperform, no facts to the contrary will ever be accepted by him. He will always mark it up to being unlucky.
It really was a terrible bet for Ted, because it has heavily publicized his fund of funds incompetence to his customers and potential customers.
These days it feels like the answer to you question is "one, on average"
Moreover, each peak will tend to exceed the previous, so it's unsurprising that Buffet's side is going smoothly. I believe in a universe run on the principle of maximal irony, so I foresee Seidel losing the bet, but by about 3-4 months.
Seidel literally got a market crash that occurs maybe once every 25 to 50 years and still couldn't win this bet. If he got two crashes he'd still lose because his hedge funds are rowing backwards 4% a year due to high fees.
Yeah hedge funds suck because they have high fees, but there's this Buffet-worshipping 'common man' implication that 'common man' should not be jealous of the rich man that has access to hedge funds because the S&P is just as good.
Maybe I'm not remembering correctly, but wasn't there a bit of research a few years ago that showed that most investors performed worse than throwing darts randomly at a dart board (of stocks)?
EDIT: Obviously, I know next-to-nothing about the stock market (etc.).