Actually it should taper off, if you make 48K and get a raise to 50K, you just got screwed.
Actually it should taper off, if you make 48K and get a raise to 50K, you just got screwed.
(The fundamental idea behind B.I. is that anyone should get it, the poorest guy in the neighborhood should get exactly as much as Bill Gates - there is some debate about convicts and/or minors, even if in the latter case most seem to agree that the money goes to the parents/caregivers).
Gates is paying at least 8 figures in Federal taxes a year, just send him a check like everyone else.
How many people are you going to hire, and how much of everyone's time are you going to waste just to stop Gates from getting a UBI payment out of spite?
Universal means just that: everyone gets it. No matter if they need it or not. Maybe you could read up something about the Alaska Fund Dividend to get an idea of how this is supposed to work in practice (the AFD is of course limited to Alaska, and way lower than the suggested 12000 USD target, but still gives an idea of how it is regulated and paid out in practice).
GBI is employed to give everyone a quality of life, but even the poorest citizen who--is getting free money, can then afford to be taxed the flat rate.
Say you have 45k average income per person. and 250 million adults.
That is (45,000 * 250,000,000) * .18 = 2,025,000,000,000 or 2 Trillion..
This doesn't factor in any Corporate / Estate / Wallstreet Speculation Taxes either. -- Which corporations should pay something similar to the 18% flat tax as well. Do that and you can almost see this thing paid for. We could also add a 4% sales tax or vat -- which will make it so anyone who's in the country on visa/illegal still pays taxes while here.
This is all speculation as I don't know the exact average incomes, and # of adults, or if children will be given stipends, or what the perfect % flat tax is for everyone - but it's just an idea.
Then it's no longer UBI, it's just another wage/welfare cliff.
Edit: oh, come on. UBI is a form of welfare. It supposedly is to make sure everyone's basic needs are met. Play with words all you want, but that is welfare.
It's not. It's fundamentally different from current welfare programs. that are complete with shortsighted baggage like income caps that are either so low they screw over the middle class, or so high they only exist to spite the high-income earners actually paying the taxes. Either case requires a whole bureaucracy to fund and hassle for everyone.
Well, yes. But that does not mean it isn't "welfare". It's for the welfare of the citizens of this country.
These policy discussions are weird, people focus really closely on the nominal mechanisms and ignore effective impacts.
The good news is that it would be funded by taxing people with higher incomes more. So people with high incomes wouldn't see any benefit from the UBI, they'd be paying for it. The difference is largely administrative and exactly how the benefit tapers off, not whether the (effective!) benefit tapers off or not.
Simpler and much more fair than an arbitrary cut off.