We have some sort of "rule of thumb", if you will, that reads "don't talk (to the police) they might write you down as a witness"
Though situations are a bit different, the overall message probably applies here too.
Also, if there is a law that could be abused, no matter how good the intention of the law is, it will be abused.
This is why I cheer up EFF for standing up for the people of the united states, even in contraversial cases that might involve actual criminals.
Trouble is, in the short term this means more crimes get solved, but in the longer term it means everybody automatically denying that they saw anything, and more crimes go unsolved.
These types of warrants are incredibly, incredibly counterproductive for justice.
It was not obvious that talking to the cops in this case would end up with him later being arrested at work and losing his job. Even the judge, once having the situation explained to her, released him and now expects a higher standard of evidence from the DA who clearly overstated the situation according to the social norms we expect. I'm glad that there are people who stand up for what is wrong, even when they personally suffer as a result. Rosa Parks was fired too!
Meaning that the only thing the police and DA worried about in this instance was to get the gang leader in jail, not what effect their means and methods had on their witness.
Never thought I'd say this; but as someone who has had problems w/ cops in the past; they seem to be MUCH more courteous. I think it is a combo of things; I am older, have been out of trouble a few years; etc. I am white (which helps) but having 5+ positive experiences-- 1 of which could've been serious; cops have been great!
Idk if there has been a push to retrain them or policy changes but I have been impressed.
It's weird never having a positive experience until recently; and I am still very on guard; but not all police are the enemy. Prosecutors like that; bad cops-- they exist and I would never be complacent around them-- but there are people working in a broken system who are good and helpful. My $0.02
So we shouldn't investigate any crimes then?
(I agree with you that putting victims in jail without rights is a horrible practice and should be stopped, but your post sounds closer to getting rid of police alltogether)