Hacker News Reader

Reading some of the "no" comments. Red Hat and IBM both have a list of reasons why they think Jigsaw is not ready.

As for the rest of the companies voting "no" it looks like it's mostly because "there is not a consensus amongst the EC". Which might be a fancy way of saying "If Red Hat and IBM don't approve then nor shall I".

View on HN

I think that isn't entirely fair. Several are quite careful in their wording ("the spec as submitted", meaning the things that are still being worked on need to be sorted out), and significant progress has been made since the spec was submitted. I doubt the EG will achieve a consensus on all issues, but if I had to guess I'd say it will go through no the second vote.

Disclaimer: These are my views, not my employers, I'm not involved in the JPMS work.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com