1. Because installing (frivolous) user utilities should not have the ability to write to critical system files, by default at least.
2. Because there's no make uninstall.
I've had this argument with others who get similarly worked up about homebrew as you seem to. I think the problem may be that you're thinking about installing core system utilities, whereas we're talking about installing all our frivolous user-domain software. So whatever package we happen to have read about and thought "oh I'll try that out". Prior to using OS X for the last 6 years my personal laptop ran Linux for the 10 years prior to that. Not everything was available via apt-get, and I know from far too much first-hand experience the dangers of installing software with root permissions, and not being able to reverse the process, so there's really no question in my mind that you're wrong; I suspect we must be answering subtly different questions as I said above.
Can you explain why you're emphasizing global software? You sound like you're talking about being a sys admin for a shared computing resource. We are just talking about our laptops.
Very occasionally we put on the hat of "administrator" of our laptop, but mostly we have on the hat of "the single user".
Now, how about my question: if it's as bad as people like you say, then why does it work so well for so many people?