To take a Steve Jobs'ism, once tech advances sufficiently you have to introduce qualities that may have nothing to do with tech, to make things more pleasing to us humans.
Programming robots to stack blocks directly is pretty easy.
Didn't Deep Blue do the same thing as part of its chess training in the 1990s? Social/observational/modeling learning has been studied in psychological research for over 50 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_learning_theory Isn't basically every recommender system, all of the vision systems, and the machine translation we all use... isn't all of that just observational learning?
I'm not saying it's not interesting. It's a cool toy. But Elon Musk gets an idea for a neat machine learning toy, using an idea that predates AI as a field, and Terry Winograd is supposed to be impressed by this?
The point is, AI has only been narrowly successful. Narrow success is rad. I'm not hating. But none of the promises of broad intelligence have really progressed. Siri is not a particularly meaningful advance beyond SHRDLU. Instead of just stacking blocks, she stacks text on Messages.app and pushes buttons in Weather.app.
More generally, it uses a deep neural network. Which is very different than the older approaches you mention, and can learn much more sophisticated functions. And has enabled a lot of results that would have been unimaginable previously.
As for the early AI researchers? They were insanely overly optimistic about how difficult AI would be. It didn't seem like a hard problem. They thought they could just assign a bunch of graduate students to solve machine vision over the summer. It seems pretty simple. We can see great without even thinking about it, how hard can it be?
But after biting their teeth into it a bit, I'm sure they would appreciate our modern methods. They might not be as elegant as they hoped. They wanted to find "top down" solutions to AI. Simple algorithms based on symbolic manipulation and logic and reasoning. Such an algorithm probably doesn't exist, and an enormous amount of the history of AI was wasted searching for it.
And even if they did discover our modern methods much earlier, they wouldn't have been able to use them. It's only recently that computers have gotten fast enough to do anything interesting. It's like they were trying to go to the moon with nothing but hand tools. Sometimes you just need to wait for the tech tree to unlock the prerequisite branches first.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1oJzUSlTeY
Obviously, it's not entirely equivalent to what's described in the article, but the point still stands.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pb3z2w9gDg&list=PLUl4u3cNGP...
We have had hundreds of thousands of software engineers working in advertising companies or making hardware that gets used to sell products and keep the attention of the youth perpetually captured, hindering their growth as humans. I say we've regressed in a big way and they would think the same.
Check out Alan Kay's talks from this week if you still feel good about today's software industry.
Of course they imagined abstracts just like we do.
Yeah I saw it great videos.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDM33CMJvp8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIR6Rmhm3To
(I'm trying to watch all of his recent talks. Despite [or because of?] being critical of the industry, they are some of the most inspiring videos I've seen in years.)
https://hci.stanford.edu/winograd/
http://web.media.mit.edu/~minsky/
Since both cooperated with DARPA at a high level they were aware of defense-related efforts which your typical AI grunt wouldn't necessarily see.
Also both are extraordinarily imaginative and bright, so it is more likely they could show you things they've done that you would not imagine.
That doesn't change that I think there is a bunch of things they didn't imagined and I think they would both agree. (Minsky unfortunately can't anymore)
And sure they can probably see things I can't it's not a competition.