Arbitrary and capricious.
while (1) { for user in userlist {
# Top .01% of users are abusive and we boot them
if usage_distribution_top(user, .0001) {
disable_account(user);
send_acctdisabled_notice_to_user(user, "Excessive usage of unlimited storage");
}
} sleep 1; }
Hours later: "How have we lost half our customers? We only ever removed the top .01% for their 'abusive' usage of our unlimited service!"
If the concept isn't clear to some people, the problem is this: You can't repeatedly cull the outliers — the top x% of the distribution — because by culling you shift the distribution to create more outliers.
I'm sure businesses recognize that, intuitively if not explicitly in their planning meetings, and therefore cull rarely enough that it doesn't impact the bulk of users (in part due to influx of new users). So you cull the top x%... who decides what x is, and why, if you state in your promotional material that the service is unlimited? "If we set x to .001% and cull monthly, it'll help our bottom line. Those users are scum data hoarders anyway and we won't serve their kind with our 'unlimited' storage service." That should be lawsuit-worthy.
Companies in this situation should be forced to specify a fixed usage limit (exactly what these companies don't want to do), or live with the outliers.