PCA doesn't perfectly control away population structure, especially if you have cryptic tiny subpopulations in your dataset that only few individuals are in. In that case you don't have enough signal to establish the subpopulations. It's also a function of the way you call your SNPs - if you don't have enough SNPs, or focus on a different method, PCA won't magically know about those unobserved populations.
I don't think they were being sarcastic though, because the rest of their replies are pretty serious.
Comments like these are why I come to HN
This sounds really interesting, how does that work exactly?
"Around 90% of experts believed that genes had at least some influence on cross-national differences in cognitive ability."
[0]http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00...
Researchers have conducted many studies to look for genes that influence intelligence. Many of these studies have focused on similarities and differences in IQ within families, particularly looking at adopted children and twins. These studies suggest that genetic factors underlie about 50 percent of the difference in intelligence among individuals.
https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/traits/intelligence
So, going with the NIH, I'd say about half.
At these sample sizes, that is an interesting idea. Has anyone checked?
(also, do include some marker of sarcasm in your comments, it can get confusing)
Why do you believe that PCA successfully captures all the relevant population structure? Probablistically, it's a Gaussian linear model... no reason to expect allele frequencies to follow that. If that were the case, methods like coalescent theory would be unnecessary.
Why do you believe that high genetic correlations between cohorts is sufficient to ensure safe inference from GWAS meta analysis? These are tiny effect sizes, and the argument is essentially that the correlations with intelligence measurements are statistically significant. Unless you believe that your null model is an otherwise entirely accurate reflection of how the data is generated, of course you're going to see spuriously significant results in huge samples.
I'll respond to your other points when/if I catch up on the literature. I'd be grateful if you could link the papers about the enrichment sets and tissue expression results.