Could school subjects soon be a thing of the past in Finland?
bbc.com
bbc.com
> "This way of teaching is great for the brightest children who understand what knowledge they need to take away from an experiment. It allows them the freedom to learn at their own pace and take the next steps when they are ready to," he says.
> "But this is not the case for children who are less able to figure it out for themselves and need more guidance. The gap between the brightest and the less able has already begun widening and I am very afraid that this will only get worse".
I had this integrated science program at IMSA (http://www.imsa.edu) in the late 90's. It was certainly interesting. We started off talking about the Yucca Mountain nuclear waste storage site. Overall, it was a fun program, and IMSA is meant to try out new teaching strategies, but I'm not sure how much of a success it would be in all public schools.
It is very important to connect various scientific and learning concepts. Sometimes it even makes it easier to learn (physics and calculus are peas and carrots). But there is a certain foundation that also needs to be built up, such as atomic theory and chemistry.
Right now we kind of teach school like a layer cake, where each layer is a grade. There's some stuff, and it vaguely builds on each other, but it's not directly connected. But whatever isn't directly connected on that graph is hard to find a use for. That's why it's important to connect concepts and understand how they interact in the world. I do think there's the possibility of a path that is more winding, connecting concepts along the way, but I'm not sure we know what the best path is. Should we focus earlier on math and reading? More science later after basic reading? Right now we seem to more or less equally divide time over subjects, which seems hugely arbitrary.
It's too bad, but doesn't that just mean that the better students have been held back by the previous system and they're finally getting what they need? The slower students need something else, but I hope that the better ones continue getting better education that they can use.
When they say "gap between the brightest and the less able has already begun widening", I think they're just starting to see again the gap that has always been there but was 'closed' at the expense of the smart kids. And it is at their expense, I've seen very bright students lose interest or turn to mischief because classes were not sufficiently stimulating for them. The smartest kid from my high school class was constantly getting in trouble and was almost expelled because he was perpetually bored.
And yes, gifted children actually need somewhere to go. I can only imagine what would have happened if the education system supported me rather than held me back. In primary school we did have a very small "gifted" program that was after school, with Apple computers, a little programming even, and learning games. Even later on, the advanced classes were boring, but way ahead of "normal classes."
Example: One time we moved schools, the new school didn't get my records, so they put me in all remedial programs without even letting me know. I was literally learning long division by hand in 7th grade, which I already knew. The next year (it took them all year to figure it out and move me up), I was taking algebra in 8th grade. What a waste of a few years.
The students seem to agree, sometimes after a transition when they realize the class is about skills more than facts. The students are adults and give reviews like
"Absolutely. I would recommend this course not just to peers, but anyone interested in leadership. Honestly, even if you don't care about being a leader, this is the kind of class which can help anyone grow as a person, not only bettering themselves in terms of leadership, but also in terms of self actualization. The social skills you learn in this class have never been taught to me in an academic environment."
and
"This course teaches leadership not just by reading theory, but actually putting the theory into practice. In most classes we are forced to regurgitate information back to the professor, in this class we are taught to be self-accountable, which is a skill everyone should have. What I learned in this class will stick with me for life. I can't say that about every SPS class. This course was refreshing."
The faculty, on the other hand, have a hard time fitting these courses into their subject-based system, independent of the value to the students.
It's like universities are asking to be disrupted.
Lean is about integration and removing arbitrary walls between types of knowledge. Hopefully today's Fordist mass production is soon replaced by Finland's lean education system. But remember, it will have nothing to do with iPads.
Pasi Sahlberg is the expert to listen to: "I don’t believe that the PISA results in Finland have anything to do with the language or the fact that Finland is more homogenous than others[.] Of course Finland has had fewer non-Finnish speakers or children who were born outside of Finland, but that cannot explain the progress in previous PISA studies or the declining results in maths." http://yle.fi/uutiset/osasto/news/finlands_school_system_the...
EDIT: Same misconception propagated by BBC in the article here (for "balance"?): "Success has been attributed to a traditionally high regard for teaching and reading, as well as a small, largely homogenous population" How would population size contribute to the averages? Who has attributed? In the BBC archives I can find that claim by some right-wing British think tank.
(in case this is regional: I'm Australian)