Lexmark: "For $20 you can lease one of our fine cartridges for an indeterminate period of time. Just need your signature on page 2, 5, and 6 of this contract."
Canon, Panasonic, HP, Xerox: "You give me $20; I give you cartridge."
2) I pay $3 a month for HP's Instant Ink program. It allows me to print up to 50 full-color pages a month with my inkjet printer, and when one of the cartridges is running low, it automatically sends a replacement. It's not significantly more expensive, in my case (low-volume usage), than buying the ink cartridges directly, but it's a lot more convenient. I'm not quite sure if it technically counts as a leasing program, but it follows a similar ethos. So I wouldn't so easily dismiss the idea that a leasing program would lead to a consumer backlash.
They tell the company "I threw it away".
People throwing used printer cartridges away would probably happen a lot, anyway, right?
Technically it would break the contract but the issue is that it would be very difficult to enforce.
2. I have to think it's pretty hard to establish that a consumable is subject to a lease. What is returned at the end of the lease?