There are models that are more powerful than TMs, but the ones I know about have "unreasonable" powers. The one that comes to mind came from A.K. Dewdney (I think); it does an unbounded amount of work in a single time step by having an unbounded number of computational units. And that is just not kosher.
So there is a certain amount of circumstantial evidence for the definition of "computable" being something like a Turing machine. And this definition of computable has limits, as in Godel (never thought I'd miss my phone's keyboard) and Turing.
As you describe, Lucas, Penrose, and others such as Searle want to walk a very fine line. They want to claim that the human mind is not limited in the way that computable functions are limited, which I understand; it certainly doesn't feel like I am so limited. On the other hand, they want to avoid going off the edge into full-blown mysticism: dualism and ye immortal soul.
Unfortunately for those like me (and I know I am) who take materialism somewhat seriously, their arguments feel more like the post-Darwin arguments that, yes, animals and stuff do evolve like that, but people are different. The closed set of computational models of TM-equivalence do seem to capture "computable functions", and those computable functions do seem to cover what is possible from any system built on biology, chemistry, and ultimately physics. Their arguments seem to be either making a distinction that doesn't make a difference, or sneaking in supernatural powers. (You can see the truth or falsehood of a statement without a proof? Reliably?)
So arguments for a non-algorithmic middle ground between TM-equivalence and "quantum woo" (great phrase, btw) are giving me problems. If I am a mixed bag of incomplete and inconsistent, with limited rationality that is not well described as a formal system but is weaker than a Turing machine, as I suspect I am, then the appearance of a non-algorithmic process is simply a misunderstanding.
On the other hand, if the non-algorithmic goings-on are correct, "quantum woo" feels like the most reasonable description of their powers. I'd really like some strong, unarguable evidence before I accept that step.