The only good open source CAD program I've found is SolveSpace (http://solvespace.com/). It's a bit of a weird program but actually works well.
The only good open source CAD program I've found is SolveSpace (http://solvespace.com/). It's a bit of a weird program but actually works well.
[1] https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD/graphs/contributors
[2] https://freecadweb.org/wiki/CompileOnWindows
I use it on the regular for making small mechanical parts for 3d printing. When I was on windows I used autodesk inventor for this, but that doesn't work on linux, so here I am.
It's certainly got some issues, but they can be sidestepped with some basic experience. I wouldn't recommend it to an engineering design firm, but I'd happily suggest it to a student startup, at least to try and see if it works for them before they spring several grand for autodesk. Mostly I'm just happy that it continues to be worked on, and look forward to each new version.
It's the only program I know that's able to directly import files from OpenSCAD.
I like to do a rapid sketch on OpenSCAD and then add fillet or chamfer in FreeCAD.
It also does good extruding of svg drawings.
I have tried other software, from Rhino (>$1000) to Onshape (free) but none match the simplicity of this workflow: openscad or svg to freecad, then export to .step
It also has a nifty 3D printing addon that is useful for cleaning up a mesh. I've started using blender almost exclusively for my 3D prints because by the time I spin up my Windows VM and pull a SolidWorks license I would have my mostly simple models done in blender.
I have not really tried blender yet; is there a simple tutorial that you would recommend?
There are a lot of great resources online. BlenderGuru is probably the most popular.
This is one I came across here on HN that I like
https://learntemail.sam.today/blog/blender-for-hackers-3d-mo...
0.16 is fairly good. I used it to design a microscope assembly. It took a ton of time to learn all the features required but once i did, it was fairly straightforward. I'd probably switch to Inventor or something else if I had the time (my coworkers use OnShape, which looks good enough for the basic stuff we do).
To me the advantage of FreeCAD is, well, it's free, and it runs on all the major platforms (IE I don't have to leave Linux to use it).
The technical weak point that will always hold it back is the kernel, Open CASCADE, when compared with Parasolid, which powers OnShape.
Parasolid is in effect subsidized by the Industrial-Military complex.
It was started in 1987 - around 20 developers then. [1]
I would guess (conservatively) that they have at least 10 developers still working on it now in 2017. An average of 15 developers over 30 years - gives around 450 person-years - all paid for by the Industrial-Military complex that funds the opaque behemoth that is Siemens PLM. [2]
Disclaimer: Parasolid dev 1989-1995.
[1] That doesn't include customer support etc - IIRC department headcount was over 40.
[2] To quote GrabCAD founder Hardi Meybaum in his Kindle ebook The Art of Product Design: "Although Siemens is a public company the PLM division is such a small part of its total business that very little financial information specific to the PLM division is released."
You make it sound like a bad thing when it's actually a solution. What you in effect said was there is a pile of money in defense contracts that can be used to subsidize development of FOSS tools. Some people are doing this (esp Galois Inc). Whoever was trying to make FOSS CAD happen didn't do this and still isn't. If they want high-quality CAD, they need to figure out how to get defense sector funding paid, skilled programmers to build the hardest parts with easy extensions by volunteering contributors. I've seen enough people in defense sector griping online about low-quality CAD tools they have that there's certainly demand. Probably just needs to be priced much lower than a lot of the others.
The #2 kernel ACIS by Spatial is massively held back by albatross round its neck - ie. the parent company Dassault who have foisted there own IMO inferior kernel CGM on them in the bizarre belief that it is a technical marvel.
Dassault is also the albatross round the neck of another subsidiary: SOLIDWORKS [1], and is famous for the $6.18 billion cost overrun when Airbus transitioned the A380 from the Catia V4 kernel to the Catia V5 kernel, which is essentially CGM. [2]
My point was that it is very difficult for OpenCASCADE with its setup to compete with 450 person-years of core dev work on essentially $0 funding.
[1] "One of the non-technical issues with CGM will probably be licensing costs. DS (and, hence, Spatial) is “proud” of CGM, and will be pricing it higher than ACIS."
http://www.3dcadworld.com/spatial-acis-cgm-and-the-future-of...
IMO that's the reason that OnShape exists at all though - the rockstar team that founded Solidworks finally got fed up with Dassault and decided to write Solidworks for the cloud.
ShapeManager by Autodesk is probably the technical #2, and is doing well. You can't buy it easily though. It powers Inventor/Fusion360 and is also in Revit and AutoCAD.
The hacker spirit in action. Roll up one's sleeves, write some code, and give a big FU to the establishment. :)
FreeCAD Arch is a smart pivot: they just need to do a hard fork from the rest of FreeCAD and replace Open CASCADE with CGAL.
History based parametric MCAD is hugely resource intensive and the 800lb gorilla SOLIDWORKS is formidable.
Best idea stay away!
If that doesn't put you off:
(1) replace history based with direct modeling
(2) have a single curved surface type of G1 (and approx G2) sheets of some closed set of implicit quartic surfaces - e.g. Dupin Cyclides or some appropriate generalization. Get very good at intersecting these!
[1] I've exited all 3D. Even the areas with dynamic markets, such as 3D-printing and augmented reality, are oversupplied with talent.
I've heard of Galois Inc. Isn't that where Don Stewart one of the RWH authors worked for a while? Looking a the Galois team on their webpage he doesn't seem to be there now.
There seems to be far more opportunity in crypto related stuff than anything CAD right now. It's a matter of opinion whether any particular crypto currency is a bubble but in the long term, blockchain technology isn't going to just go away and that surely must disrupt markets for years to come.
So, even though I know a lot more about CAD, I've actually just started working on my own AGPL3 crypto toolkit in a private GitHub repository in the hope that I can build a consultancy business around it and maybe do the dual-licensing thing.
Far as crypto, there's currently a rush or bubble on blockchains. Definitely a chance for you to make money on the hype. There's also a lot of competition (noise). That will undermine you a bit. Good luck.
I only have two issues with freecad
1. the constant switching between workspaces is annoying. we need less workspaces, better tools.
2. important functions such as assembly have been in development for years and are still not ready for use