Because an individual choosing privacy implicitly chooses privacy for everyone, but an individual choosing 'safety' (in this context) implicitly chooses no privacy for everyone else, and implicitly unsafety for people who needed that privacy while not actually doing anything illegal. (Or maybe doing something technically illegal but still just or reasonable or morally right).
It's an "I have nothing to hide, so you cannot hide anything", "I'm alright jack", "everyone should trust the people I trust because I agree with them" approach.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4571186/May-cut-poli...
This also isn't just privacy - they want to ban websites with content they find extreme on. Democracy doesn't work without the ability to discuss ideas.
They talk about Islamic extremists, and you say "sure, that ideology is evil", then maybe they go after proponents of assisted suicide - after all, it's illegal and they are suggesting doctors kill people! Then maybe someone else gets into power and they ban abortion - can't set up a website suggesting people kill babies! Or perhaps someone else gets in and says "This party wants to defund the NHS! People will die, better ban that!".