Open source Cocoa implementation for Windows and Linux
code.google.com
code.google.com
This difference in philosophy becomes evident in some practical ways:
* Cocotron is designed for integration as a cross-compiler within Xcode. You can literally copy your Mac app or framework target and retarget it to Windows or Linux with a few clicks in Xcode. (GNUstep also does cross-compilers in theory, but integrating with Apple's IDE is not their prime focus because GNUstep traditionally has had its own Next-derived dev environment.)
* Cocotron has a minimum of dependencies and tries to be very lightweight. Its Foundation and AppKit DLLs are just a few megabytes.
* Cocotron aims for a platform-native look, at least as far as possible within the constraints of Mac OS X resource and code compatibility.
* Cocotron's stated goal is Cocoa compatibility. It does not have its own public API extensions, unlike GNUstep.
More info would certainly facilitate developer adoption to what seems like (at the very least) a pretty interesting project. Kudos to the developers - looking forward to hearing more about it.
Translation: No GUI on Linux or Solaris.
Cocotron is licensed under MIT. Assuming that the GNUStep authors want to maintain a stricly GPL codebase, they would not want to borrow anything from cocotron. The authors of cocotron chose MIT specifically to be friendlier for commercial developers.
[I assumed that AfterStep was implemented with GNUStep, but I just looked at the dependency list, and it doesn't include GNUStep...]
The problem for me, is the menu system - in theory it really looks cool, that you can detach menus, and leave them as commands (which modern UI's don't do, except maybe Autodesk Maya).
But then I just can't get used to it - give me Window's menus, or Mac OS X ones, or Gnome/KDE and I'm fine - I just can't adjust to the NextStep/OpenStep/GNUStep (okay, my casing is bad here).
Oh, and GTK runs on far more platforms than Cocoa (Cocoa runs on Macs and iPhones/iPads, whereas you'd be able to use GTK on Mac, Windows, desktop and handheld Linux, as well as other Unix flavors)
For example the Clozure Associates, have put in their open sourced common lisp - ccl the cocotron, and it's available from there.