That means you will have to scrap any strict "lowest bid wins" laws. You also need public servants who know what they are talking about, and can filter out both bids that are too good to be true (you don't want the winner of the tender to go bankrupt half-way through the project or to use materials that are barely good enough) and bids that are insanely high.
One fairly recent innovation that apparently works well is to put out a tender for the combination of construction and x years maintenance.
That will get you bids from consortia consisting of a construction companies, companies specializing in cleaning, and companies specializing in maintenance.
So, what's the difference? Those companies will talk to each other before the design is finalized. You will get proper weighing of "is that paint truly cheaper in the long run?" and "if you add a few hooks to that bridge deck, we won't have to spend a week every five years building scaffolding so that we can inspect the bridge".
I mean the whole conservative argument about the value of the free market for moderating health care costs is completely blown up by the most cursory look at the value you get for private health insurance in the UK due to the fact that they have to compete with free. But there's no attention span in the political debate to put forth an argument like that because it doesn't align with an established narrative and therefore can be triggered by a sound-bite-sized emotional appeal. You need a years-long strategy and talking points to chip away at it, but the people with the knowledge and facts to do so are not good political strategists, and the people with the time and inclination to do so all have vested interests in the current system.
I disagree that they have to compete with free because they effectively compete with free footing parts of the bill and that is ideal. If you take the UK and you have a private insurance (like Bupa) you don't have private insurance instead of the NHS (the public one) but in addition to the NHS.
One the one hand this means that I have the choice as a customer to go with an NSH or Bupa service, but I also know that the NHS will always take me and Bupa knows that I will think like that. Bupa knows that people are very unlikely to charge the private insurance for an ambulance (because why would I? The gov pays). However they know I will use their services when I had a mountaineering accident and need a helicopter. They fundamentally operate in largely different areas that just happen to overlap in some parts. Sometimes people use a private insurance because they don't want to wait. But that often also means they don't have to wait not because they will die because then the state system (unless it's temporarily broken) will prioritize you anyways.
I think splitting the problem into two (emergency care vs. 'lifestyle' care) would work in the US but that's not the conversation that is taking place and that is a cultural thing more than it is a problem of politics.
I really think that looking abroad has a point. As an example, for Swiss railway managers it has been a regular occurance to go abroad and learn from other countries what they do better and what to avoid.
The US is just a nation and Americans are just humans, like everyone else - trying to stop with the "we are special" thinking would give the US quite a boost in certain areas IMO.
This is what makes infrastructure cheap in Europe. The Swiss rail companies build infrastructure for Switzerland primarily (unless they are contracted out) and not for all of Europe.
My utopia would be an virtualized, decoupled administration system based on the blockchain and decentralized contracts. I can simply choose what org I want to be citizen of and subscribe to them. An org would itself subscribe to a set of infrastructure and get volume rebates. Each piece of infrastructure has a blockchain address - if I want to use it and I'm not subscribed, I just pay as I go. Essentially, free market meets governance. Some exceptions where IMO socialism works best: Schooling, National defense, emergency services and Healthcare. Same high standards and opportunities for everyone.
Like, its somehow completely incomprehensible to people that the Germans might have devised a better system for running trains (they build better trains, so not so far-fetched) or that the Japanese might have a better grasp on building quality public transportation than we do.
Rather, there's this idea that the American way of doing things must be the absolute best in every possible situation. Its a very damaging idea, and historically has led to stagnation and collapse (Qing dynasty China comes to mind as a great example of this).
The mindset is the same as in any other country - the polls say people prefer single payer in spite of all the propaganda thrown their way.
While the UK was debating forming the NHS back in the 1940s the Conservative party fought to put in place an insurance based system largely like America has today. If they had been a little more powerful after the war the UK would likely face similar problems.
The article specifically notes that the US pays more for infrastructure than other more heavily NIMBY nations, and pays more than other nations that have more strict land-use laws than the US has.