I take your point. However there is one case where traditional cab companies provide a benefit. When a city issues permits for the lucrative airport business to one specific cab company, it is with the understanding that there will be cars waiting for passengers around the clock, even during unprofitable times of the day.
If the cab business becomes a free-for-all, there will be no one waiting at the airport at 3:00 AM. Granted, there isn't a lot of traffic at certain times, but the public interest is best served when there are always cabs available.