Hacker News Reader

Comment by kakarot | Hacker News Reader

You and your fellow citizens are incapable of organizing against your government in the event that it becomes dangerous to its constituents. Congratulations!

I am glad to live in a country whose founders had the foresight that allowing a government to leverage weaponry / violence against its citizens without giving its citizens the same leverage was just a bad, bad idea.

That is the real reason for the 2nd amendment, not so I can defend myself against home intruders. That is a secondary argument.

View on HN

Except that this time the difference between a regular army and a militia would be far beyond just the color of their coat.

Having weapons at home can barely counter law enforcement, let alone a professional military force.

This time there's more technology supporting each area of warfare: logistics, reconnaissance, equipment, vehicles...

A militia, however organized, has everything to lose against an regular army in the 21st century. In fact, chances are you would die before you are in range to fire your weapon.

Your only chance to win would be insurgency or guerrilla warfare.

You are absolutely correct and it's a horrible state of affairs.

There's still no need to starve the beast and remove one of the few weapons we have against the slaughtering of our rights and freedoms.

Just being able to purchase guns of reasonable firepower without scrutiny is extremely important to the freedom of our posterity and their ability to organize.

I know this almost makes me sound like some sort of radical terrorist, but these ideals are at the core of our Constitution and to not value these ideals is to be devoid of true patriotism.

Guerilla warfare... without guns?

You're exactly right, "Your only chance to win would be insurgency or guerrilla warfare." but I'll add "with guns."

Good luck shooting at an Apache helicopter with a mounted minigun with your semi-automatic gun.

That argument would be much more effective if we didn't have groups like ISIS taking the piss out of the US.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com