Now the case for selling agents making a percentage-based commission is stronger, assuming they actually actively work to sell the home (holding open houses and active promotion).
But when it comes to buyer's agents, the whole idea of paying them based on the sale value is a massive conflict of interest. Why would a buyer's agent be a good faith representative in negotiations if it was in their personal interest that the sale price be higher?
The only reason this has worked for so long is that Realtors collude on the commission (it's 6% everywhere... there is no price competition). They also actively try to control entrance into the profession to make sure everyone tows the line.
To me, a fee-based buying agent makes much more sense. Barring that, at least pay them as a percentage of the difference between the asking and final price. That way if you get the house for $10k under the asking price, they can have 35% of that, rather than 3% of the total value of the home.