Also, an important issue with such arguments, is that generics is a feature, so obviously it is an easy side to choose for an argument. You can either have or don't have a feature. People will instinctively select the have option because common sense dictates that it is better to have something even if you don't use it. People want to quantify an argument and having is better than not having.
People don't want to argue about language design —there are few people on the planet that could really argue about language design anyway-, they need language MHz to compare.