What are some ways to counter this effect?
Or, explicitly require / assume that all applicants be fully familiar with your culture.
Or, define an industry standard artificial culture - whether implicit or explicit - and require everyone on both sides to be familiar with it. This could include things like suits and golf for execs, hoodies and beer for techies, social justice activism for webdevs, etc...
However, I can guarantee that resting on your laurels and calling your process "unbiased" from the start won't work.