the content is going to have to be extremely compelling to compete against youtube/vimeo offerings. For premium content I have a real desire or need to see (concerts, something for work/school/etc) I might pay, but possibly still would look elsewhere. I think the idea is
interesting, but you'll need to find the specific publishers that think they have the content worth paying for.
Are you timing the playtime, or putting in 'pay wall' at a specific timer in the video?
Also, going to a separate website is way too jarring - I think the experience would have to be in-player for it to be workable. I might be proved wrong, but that's my gut feeling.
Good luck!