How non-scientists think about science and science-denial
blogs.harvard.edu
blogs.harvard.edu
Theoretically, that's what peer-review is all about. Is your theory published in Nature? High confidence. Is your theory a FoxNews piece on a 'recent study'? Low confidence.
Particularly with regard to Nature, the following website might interest you: http://retractionwatch.com/category/by-journal/nature-retrac...
Which I think can be fine, specially if the experts don't have a great track record (e.g. economics and psychology). But it can also get absurd pretty quickly, like when people point out some huge snowstorm in their town in response to "global warming", as if that proves anything.
If this isn't recognized, it is used by some to say "that fact turned out to be wrong! Therefore that science is wrong!". It isn't like that. Science comes from a question, or many questions. Scientists (i.e. people) use observation to turn those questions into what they think are answers. It is this process that is science, not the facts that they produce. If all you do is focus on facts, you can't critically analyze why something shouldn't be correct, and further science by thinking about how you can explain why this isn't the case. So you end up with arguments about facts instead of arguments about why observations and perceptions are different, which is what science is supposed to be about.
My 2.2c.
Vaccines: good science
Cold fusion: bad science
PTSD: good science
Aryan Race: bad science
All or nothing is indeed the wrong way to look at it.