There are so many visible as well as hidden factors that attempting to measure any (let alone all) of that is a pipe dream.
Also, by writing the second one you are not accounting for second version effects since it is a reimplementation of something you know, and if someone else develops it for you then you just changed a major variable.
I get that you said "oversimplified", but this is just like saying "thought experiment", yet as soon as you confront that to the real world, it just doesn't realistically fly.