This is how science in the USA should work?
This is how science in the USA should work?
More so when the new EPA policy depends of a subjective matter and we know what the position of the new chief is.
So what am I imagining the judicial branch to do?
Assume the new leadership of the EPA decides to introduce some new policy based on bogus cherry-picked studies that deny the reality of climate change. When people rightfully complain that this is not the "best available science", the case goes to a judge.
The judge now has to decide whether or not the HONEST act was violated. To do that, since they are themselves not in a position to judge the science involved, they will likely have to rely on expert testimony. Given the overwhelming consensus in the scientific literature, a judge would have to be quite crooked indeed not to find that studies that completely fail to reflect this are not the "best available science". They should thus find in favor of environmentalists against the EPA.
Am I too naive in imagining this outcome?
Look at the court cases involving Purdue Pharma and Oxycontin, or Phillip Morris and Cigarettes, or any of the oil companies and their oil spills, or Nestlé and cases involving its water sources, or look at the government and gerrymandering. The evidence of judges identifying sound science and it affecting their decisions in major cases - those involving large amounts of money - is not comforting.
But if that doesn't convince you, then perhaps you can show us where in the Constitution the judiciary is delegated this power to define truth.
Have you never heard the cautionary story of Galileo?