Well the standard and reasonable definition that has existed for longer than a decade is that no-reply implies that there is no one actually reading the emails you send. Its an indicator that its an automated system, and replying or sending emails to this address will get you no where but a black hole.
The unreasonable action is giving someone 30-days to change their email, considering how integral email's are to security these days (password resets etc...) Eastlink made the mistake of allowing this, now they are forcing someone else to pay.