It's not just that he calls him out for it, but that he does it so early on the piece before any real context is given, including what the actual problem is. We're just told that git is severely fucked, and that the problems can be isolated to 2 commits, even though the author fails to make contact with the commiter to give him a chance to make a defense.
> Well, I posted a question on the Git mailing list to ask, but the Git mailing list is so noisy that I doubt that anybody will ever answer my question, least of all Hamano. But I can speculate as to why; if I were Hamano, I probably would have made the same mistake.
And no, posting to the mailing list, which the author himself admits is too noisy for the commiter to have likely noticed, is not a real effort to make contact given the severity and self-assured nature of the assertion, which suggests to me that the author is lazy in other ways that make his analysis suspect. Seriously, the author is so cocksure about the problem, and yet too timid to email Hamano, who is on Github and has a listed email address?
It's an appalling lack of basic courtesy, never mind intellectual curiousity.