Charts about Wealth Inequality in America
apps.urban.org
apps.urban.org
A sad state of affairs for the "greatest country in the world".
Don't you mean Kansas?
If you want to thoroughly understand the problem so that you can reason intelligently about what a solution might look like, you'll probably want more data.
Lots of other things happened in the period in that graph which kept median incomes lower despite economic improvements taking place. Like:
1. The offering of health insurance as a tax-free employment benefit.
2. An increase in divorce rates (households all over cut in half but the median household income didn't drop; there must have been an economic gain distributed to not-rich people for this to happen).
Also, this graph doesn’t say anything about what happened to the size of each of these groups. Pretty sure the biggest trend in America has been the middle class splitting in half between people making more money (and thus becoming part of the "small few") and people making less (which worsens income inequality even though more people are now "rich").
So yeah, there's a lot missing from these graphs.
Not to go into every single micro sub group of income earners and divorced neurologists with company sponsored health insurance who have more income than an tech worker homeowner with 6 cats.
The graph is perfectly valid for what it represents. The share on a large sample size of hundreds of millions of people of historical income gains and results can be interpreted thusly.
http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/1970s-grea...
> Income differences narrow when all taxes and transfers—such as health insurance and in-kind government benefits—are included
https://www.minneapolisfed.org/publications/the-region/where... expounds on a few of the things that have caused household take-home pay to stagnate. The tl;dr there though is:
> Average household size declined substantially during the past 30 years, so household income is being spread across fewer people. The mix of household types—married versus single, young versus old—also changed considerably, so the “median household” in 2006 looks quite different from the “median household” in 1976. Finally, the measure of income used by the Census Bureau to compute household income excludes some rapidly growing sources of income.
Which is all to say that it's a bit more complex than a few charts might immediately make it look. Income inequality has certainly seen an increase, but it's incorrect to characterize it as the upper decile bleeding all the benefits out of the rest of the economy.
... and have a look at the "data" underneath, a three line set of data with two values coming from Melissa (link to another "local" .xlsx) and a third one which is just a number.
Most probably correct calculations, but no real way to check.
Tragedy of the commons is not a new concept.
GPs example is exactly game-theoretix tragedy of the commons / prisoners dilemma.
> Tragedy of the Commons is what happens when nobody clearly owns something that many people use, so none of them use it responsibly.
It's specifically, originally, a term for overgrazing a pastureland resulting from the kind of arrangement you described; there are a number of generalizations from that example which have been given the name, including both the one you describe, and the even more general condition in which each player has a dominant strategy of defection even though all players cooperating has a better payoff than all defecting.
The Commons need not be an overgrazed pastureland; it can be any open access resource. The best modern example would be Earth's atmosphere and how its being filled with pollution. GGP has not specified a Commons and the existence of one is not implied in his comment.
The fact that the term has long been widely accepted as a label for the general class of problems, OTOH, does.
(Arguably, the structure of the payoff matrix in the class of problems implies an economically real if intangible “commons” in any problem in the class, which is probably why the label is used that way.)
The overall effect is more uncertain than you suggest, but presumably it's clear that the 'giving' that is highly desired and publicly demanded by certain people can be implemented by them today.
Further, I'd postulate that the desire to only give if everyone gives is a rather convenient mechanism to simultaneously not give and appear virtuous.
So they had high taxes, massive redistribution that was basically compulsory. The policy was, use it or lose it. You spend it, or we spend it. You don't like how we're spending your money? OK, find a way to spend it differently, take a risk on a business, and deduct those expenses.
Taxes are so cheap at the top end that it's better to pay those taxes, and stuff the remaining money in real estate, the stock market, or bonds, than it is to take the risk on a business. Being a greedy hoarder should be very expensive in terms of taxes. WE've done it before, the country was not killed, instead it thrived. That era of high top end taxes built massive public and private infrastructure.
It's the greedy hoarders who are killing the country. Below a certain level of wealth, saving money is very good. Above a certain amount of wealth, it's very bad. Draw the line to make it really punitive to stay above that line.
Otherwise, you're just a cranky advocate for aristocracy, and oligarchy. And that's what'll kill a country.
Aristocracy is how you turn every damn thing into a product including life. Oh you're sick but you can afford health care, too bad, life is unfair, you die. Oh you're wrongly accused of murder, can't afford a good lawyer, have fun in jail, bye. It makes the entire society untrustworthy, and its stability is specious falling apart abruptly and violently. And that's what we should be trying to avoid.