Globalisation: the rise and fall of an idea that swept the world
theguardian.com
theguardian.com
Regardless of the societal cost, companies individually have to retain competitive advantage / parity. Automation will be a boon for individual companies, which means it will be an arms race among competitors in an industry. Tragedy of the commons and all.
So it doesn't matter if globalization is good or bad. It is our reality because individual companies will always be looking to gain an advantage whether that's through offshoring or automation. The impact of automation will be far worse for the individual in society than the impact of globalization.
All of this leads to even more wealth inequality as the value in the economy is increasingly captured by capital rather than labor. I think we're in for a messy few decades as we figure out how to restructure our societal institutions to work in the new world.
(If you're not up to speed, Gwern's been maintaining a good bibliography: https://www.gwern.net/Mistakes#dysgenics)
I don't for a second think Bill Gates was serious when he proposed it.
>There is no other way.
Yes, there is, a curtailing of globalization. In fact, I would say that our current way is just about the only way we can't continue. The article is about this exact feeling of inevitability. Globalization is not inevitable. A return to a time of nationalism and tarriffs is certainly possible. And unless those of us who are made relatively better-off by trade figure out a way to make the worse-off benefit too, there will be a political backlash which threatens the whole picture (see Brexit, Trump & the growth in socialist movements).
That's a brave claim.
Foxconn also promised they'd mostly all be automated away within 5 years or so, 5 years ago.
That wasn't bad capacity planning on their part. That was just a flat out lie.
That lie was repeated, uncritically by the western media at the time. 5 years later they're still repeating the prediction and the western media still reports it with not a shadow of skepticism.
I have found this sentiment very common but I haven't heard a good enough argument to support it.
If we banned all sorts of artificial energy sources like fossil fuels, solar, nuclear etc. no automation would be possible and even the ones we have would be gone. This would mean that everyone would have unlimited "jobs" (because everything currently done by machines would have to be done by hand if possible) while the standards of living would for everyone would drop significantly.
So, lets say we started from that position and gradually started allowing limited amount of fuel and automation that amount of fuel would be able to do. While this would mean that some people would have to lose jobs and switch to something else, the standard of living overall would be increased.
At what point would you say that there is "too much automation"?
When billions of people are not needed and a minority can maintain a rich/upper middle class standard of living by itself + automation, and thus, if it weren't for causing chaos and riots, those redundant masses can be left to rot and die in slums without jobs and houses.
I think this would eventually lead to less inequality, not more.
Whoever owns the robots would likely refuse to let the robots work without the owners getting paid. And even if labour is (effectively) free, resources aren't.
No, the poor simply wouldn't afford either robots or one of the remaining jobs to make enough money to buy one. And nobody would care for them. They might not even get to vote anymore.
It's either Star Trek style socialism, UBI (and trailer-park-like sub-par living for those receiving it) or direct slums.
And those with power and privilege will tend towards the latter two.
Besides, money is just a means to get material wealth and power today. If automation (+ maybe 1/10th the workers, office drones, and service workers) can maintain that material wealth, the "working economy" will be what happens between that 1/10th of the population.
They wont be selling robots and other goods to the poor masses, for the same reason they don't sell houses, cars and computers to the poor masses in slums in India, Mexico and elsewhere.
Either the economy needs them, and raises them from poverty (e.g. by giving them a factory job like in China or early USA), or it doesn't and it neglects them.
The small new rich/upper middle class that will form wont particular care for those outside it, the same way most middle class people never care about the tens of millions of "trailer trash" in the US or the homeless. It's not like many ask themselves everyday 'why don't we help our trailer part people' or do anything about.
When you do, I think you'll find that automation is not the problem, but our means of distributing access to resources. In other words, it's a false choice: in a different system, we could all receive the benefits of automation and have ready access to the abundant resources necessary for our individual sustenance.
That's an interesting question. My main problem with automation is the way it is currently being used. Rather than being used to benefit workers, i.e to mean they must work fewer hours, in many cases the workers are simply re-purposed, none of the benefit from the machinery making its way to them. It is the pursuit of short-term profit which I think is the real problem. Now the usualy response to this is something along the lines of "that's true, but the consumers benefit". But what good is the benefit of the consumer if he must still work the same amount even with the machinery?
I think it's possible to have one's cake and eat it too. The usage and appropriate advancement of machinery to the maximum (which is not currently possible) but rather than being used for profit to be used for the benefit of workers and mankind in general. Within capitalism there is a paradox: you want to automate for short-term profit, but with too much automation you run out of people to buy back the products they make, or they don't have high enough wages to do that anyway (note how very rarely can one buy back an hour of simplified labour with an hour's wage). Capitalism thrives on the fact that automation is good, but not too good.
Holding back or reversing automation is completely the wrong answer. The correct answer is to use automation to reduce labour hours and make way for the enrichment of the individual, as poet and author Oscar Wilde wrote about in his book The Soul of Man Under Socialism and indeed so did Russian anarchist philosopher Kropotkin since the 19th century. That said, I am not optimistic - overproduction will continue and the crisis cycle repeats until it is no longer sustainable, either due to the environmental impact of pursuit of profit or the contradictions of capital accumulation.
Why does it have to be one or the other? Why can't some companies profit for benefiting mankind? In fact, why would anyone bother putting their time and energy into "benefiting mankind" when someone else could do it for profit?
>Rather than being used to benefit workers, i.e to mean they must work fewer hours, in many cases the workers are simply re-purposed, none of the benefit from the machinery making its way to them.
Agricultural job was the most common job for people for several millennia. Now, most of it has been automated and only 4.2% of people in developed countries are employed in that industry. And a few people who are in the industry are very rich. Do you think everyone is richer or poorer because of it?
I think your assumption doesn't take into consideration the fact that wealth is not fixed. Automating farming away has taken away most of the farming jobs and that as a result has freed people to do something else like work in factories and produce things that didn't exist before. If 80-90% of people had to work in farm just for us to sustain (like it was the case before), our standard of living would be much worse because we would not have enough manpower to work on anything else. Just like our farming ancestors could not have envisioned what we now take for granted, I think we are incapable of imagining what we will accomplish when we are free of all the menial jobs that takes people's time today.
Well, that's precisely the problem. There's little space for people to do good in when success is based on capital accumulation.
>Automating farming away has taken away most of the farming jobs and that as a result has freed people to do something else like work in factories and produce things that didn't exist before
I think this is missing the point. The rate at which "new things" (requiring new jobs) are being created is, I believe, less than the rate at which people are born. People shouldn't have to work in factories, at least not at the amounts currently "required" today, and the only reason why they are working in such jobs is due to overproduction, less incentive to automate, and the contradiction which I mentioned in which capitalism requires a less than maximum standard of automation to function.
>I think we are incapable of imagining what we will accomplish when we are free of all the menial jobs that takes people's time today.
Are we also incapable of imagining what can be accomplished when people are free of jobs, or at least, the requirement to sell labour-power for wage? Labour-saving devices are being invented in nearly every field, and yet people are still having to work at the same rate. The rate of creation of fields without labour-saving devices (which thusly require large number of labour hours) is I believe reducing.
I see five reasons why people work so much:
1. Lack of labour saving devices in a particular field
2. Overproduction as part of the cycle of capital crisis
3. The more hours applied, the larger the amount of money the worker earns, and few hours are not enough to sustain one person or his family
4. Labourers need to buy back the products they create and they can only do this with wage and further with some "disposable" wage
5. The prevalence of government-run programmes encouraging employment rather than programmes which guarantee the ability of those with hard to sell labour-power to live without selling their labour-power (think pensions, but not just for those over the age of retirement.)
Of those reasons, you've only countered reason (1) with the reasoning that there will always be some area with few labour saving devices. I think this is a bit of a kludge (sort of like UBI in my opinion) and not something I would be willing to bank on given the rate of innovation. The problem lies in the dichotomy presented to us by our mode of production which roughly says: sell your labour-power, or live in poverty. This is alleviated (though not solved) only by government spending. I'll quote Oscar Wilde:
At present, in consequence of the existence of private property, a great many people are enabled to develop a certain very limited amount of Individualism. They are either under no necessity to work for their living, or are enabled to choose the sphere of activity that is really congenial to them, and gives them pleasure. These are the poets, the philosophers, the men of science, the men of culture – in a word, the real men, the men who have realised themselves, and in whom all Humanity gains a partial realisation. Upon the other hand, there are a great many people who, having no private property of their own, and being always on the brink of sheer starvation, are compelled to do the work of beasts of burden, to do work that is quite uncongenial to them, and to which they are forced by the peremptory, unreasonable, degrading Tyranny of want. These are the poor, and amongst them there is no grace of manner, or charm of speech, or civilisation, or culture, or refinement in pleasures, or joy of life. From their collective force Humanity gains much in material prosperity. But it is only the material result that it gains, and the man who is poor is in himself absolutely of no importance. He is merely the infinitesimal atom of a force that, so far from regarding him, crushes him: indeed, prefers him crushed, as in that case he is far more obedient.
( But Of course globalisation means they will move to lower energy country. )
That's honestly why solar will replace grid power very soon: it's near impossible to regulate because you can't cut off access to the sun. It's the difference between buying a fish at the market for dinner and buying a fishing pole.
The more I think on this though, the more I realize that corporations are probably going to become wealthier and stronger than most countries' ability to regulate them. They already have too much influence in government.
these companies don't operate in a vacuum though and have to abide by rules and regulation that either impact them directly (like tariffs on their products when importing them into the country) or "indirectly" by tax breaks or other benefits provided to their competitors who favor domestic labor etc.
Not mentioned in the article: China. China now has an official policy of autarky. It is a national objective to be as independent as possible of outside sources.[1] That's already been achieved with the Internet, using the Great Firewall of China to help China-based services compete. Google, Facebook, Skype - all blocked in China. Microsoft Windows past XP is often a special version for China for which the Chinese government has the source code.[2]
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/a-national... [2] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/03/red-f...
On the other side of the coin, Amazon and Google have probably enabled the development of other businesses in those countries. I hesitate to use the US as an example though since Amazon and Google are from the US.
WeChat is a comprehensive mobile-first service. China needed that because it's a mobile-first country.
Which is also the official policy of the US. No major nation wants to have dependencies on external sources.
> Google, Facebook, Skype - all blocked in China. Microsoft Windows past XP is often a special version for China for which the Chinese government has the source code.[2]
What shocks me is why other nations don't do this too. I am so astounded that europe hasn't developed their own google/facebook/etc via protectionism. They've conceded so much wealth by simply allowing our tech companies to take over european markets. The same goes for india.
With all due respect, facebook and even google as not hard to replicate. The concepts are simple. A handful of CS students could build one up within a few weeks. Instead, europeans have pretty much cede their markets to the US and instead of their CS students creating facebook/google/etc, they work for facebook/google/etc.
We are talking about web companies, not aerospace or automobile companies that require tons of upfront investment.
That seems to be untrue on the face of it.
China was the closest to autarky in the 60s, when it only traded with other Communist-aligned nations, and trade was <5% of GDP. Here's a picture of how it's changed [1].
Although the chart does show that share declining in past years, there's no way China will isolate itself from the world like it did 50 (or 300) years ago.
[1] http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NE.TRD.GNFS.ZS?locations...
Top US exports to China (2012):
1. Soybeans: $15 billion
2. Civilian aircraft: $8.4 billion
3. Cotton: $3.4 billion
4. Copper materials: $3 billion
5. Passenger vehicles (small engines): $3 billion
6. Aluminum materials: $2.4 billion
7. Passenger vehicles (large engines): $2.2 billion
8. Electronic integrated circuits: $1.7 billion
9. Corn: $1.3 billion
10. Coal: $1.2 billion
It's official China policy to catch up in aircraft engines [1] and ICs [2] and stop importing those. The private sector in China seems to be advancing on the automotive front, with the help of high tariffs on US car imports.[3] The US will be allowed to sell China soybeans, cotton, corn, and some coal.
[1] http://www.defenceaviation.com/2016/09/aeroengine-corporatio...
[2] https://semiengineering.com/china-unveils-memory-plans/
[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/20/business/economy/china-us...
True autarky is neither imports nor exports and aims for complete independence from external economic events. Even if all you're importing is raw materials, a spike in the price can throw your economy into a tailspin, e.g. the oil crisis of the 70s in the West.
It makes me earnestly wonder how the U.S. would have fared had we taken a protectionist stance like China (or even moreso). I get that cheap labor/manufacturing makes stuff cheaper for us, but of course it also creates downward pressure on domestic wages.
I also get that trade opens new markets for our corporations, but we do run pretty massive trade deficits with our larger partners, meaning that, on-balance, this benefit is oversold.
With higher wages and near full domestic employment, corporate profit margins would have likely been lower, though real-income may have been higher due to steady demand from high income consumers.
Anyway, just a thought exercise. Seems hard to go back from here, but I do wonder what the net result would have been.
(Source? But reasonable.) The effect is that GDP is limited by domestic consumer income, which is driven by total wages paid. Without higher wages, the U.S. economy cannot grow. More productive capacity does not help.
It's actually closer to 70%, and is an oft-quoted stat. While it is occasionally disputed by an economist here or there, it is generally accepted.
Sources are abundant. Here's one:
What drives globalization isn't the WTO, the Davos elites or evil capitalists. It is technology: steam ships, refrigeration, containers in ports, telecommunications, etc.
Other technologies will come and will accelerate this process. We will surely go beyond "global supply chains", regardless of what orange demagogues think of it.
To stop globalization, one would have to revert the entire planet to before industrial revolution. Which is entirely possible with e.g. nuclear weapons, but I don't think anyone sane would want that to happen.
Who globalization benefits, however, changes from time to time and right now the west is being dethroned.
Ironically things like nationalism only makes even more room available for other players who are more than willing to fill your void.
I don't think the "theory" of globalization has an impact on that.
There is an economic theory -- acknowledged in the article -- that people, given education, will find the jobs that are created.
Is there any reason to believe this economic theory does not hold?
This article seems to claim that politically, the idea has lost currency but the real question is: what is the reality? Can we educate people into jobs or not?