Rents businesses essentially "short circuit" the flow of capital through the economy. So a "one percenter"[1] buys a cabin which he rents through AirBnB to other "one percenters". Because he isn't a hospitality business he doesn't hire desk staff, a concierge, or pay taxes that are funding local government efforts. Instead the 'rents' just recirculate right back into the "one percenter" pool.
The absurd extreme of this notion is something like the vision in Elysium of a rich people enclave with no need of any human "non rich" staff.
I don't see that actually coming to pass but as Gates and others have noted, it is important to understand how technology can distort an economy and work on ways to repair that distortion.
[1] In quotes because it is a stand end for 'top n% where n << 50'
A: A developer is someone who wants to build a cabin in the woods; an environmentalist is someone who already has one.
If you're talking more like a 20%er, then they are either doing the same thing, or they live locally so even though they're not hiring a maid/handy-man, money is going from the 1%er to a person living in the local economy (themselves).
Assume the cabin exists. It can be owned by someone who lives in it, or someone who really just rents it. In either scenario property taxes are going to be paid. And in either scenario the cabin will be maintained by local service agencies (plumbers, electricians, etc).
The only difference might be that the 1%er is paying a laundry and maid service, and a local to pick up and give out the keys to the place.
There is no special "business property tax" for AirBnB/VRBO type rentals and according to Fresno many VRBO/AirBnB types don't actually report their income (this annoys the state equalization board), and according to the Sunnyvale city manager people who rent out rooms or their houses should have a business license but they generally don't and it is hard to enforce.
My suggestion was that if you differentiated between a VRBO/AirBnB place and a bonafide hospitality business, like a Bed and Breakfast, there is both significant additional tax revenues and additional documented employment.
If a person isn't reporting their income, that's a federal crime, and we have enforcement mechanisms for that. They might be lagging a bit, but if there's anything the government is fairly good at, it's making sure you're paying income tax.
In what way is a bonafide Bed and Breakfast going to result in additional documented employment? All of the bonafide BnBs I've stayed at were completely run and maintained by the home owners.
Nowhere that I've lived has had this. Not that I've ever lived in the US.
There's no extra property tax, but most places require sales tax to be paid on all short term rentals and many charge lodging tax on top of that.
In my case in Virgina, I pay 10.3% combined sales and lodging tax on every dollar of rent.
There is also much more wear and tear on a vacation rental than a long term property, so it's not just increased business for local maids but all construction trades, local handymen etc.
That is a good point, it is no doubt especially true for transient renters versus someone who is renting a place to live in full time.
I see why some people would not welcome growth but nobody owes you a lifetime guarantee on living in a desirable place for a low amount. It's real estate and has always been subject to change, many times severe fluctuation.
As someone who pays my taxes it is very annoying to have another body step in and muck it all up. AirBnb is notorious for collecting the wrong taxes and poorly reporting the taxes they do collect.
And many of these are people who live in day-trip distance of ski areas rather than renting or owning second homes, so the proportion in that market is even lower.
But the reality is that the resorts make their profits off a tiny percentage of the clientele. The middle class family who stays in a budget hotel, buys season passes, and brings their own food, ends up being a net loss for the company.
Practically all the money is made on the full price daily ticket sales, expensive marked up restaurants, and high end real estate sales/rentals. Without the rich people who blow $20k on a week of skiing once a year, the industry as we know it simply would not exist.