It depends on the product and the person. Google Music has saved me money. I listen to quite a bit of music and was averaging about $200/year on buying CDs. Now, I average about $50/year + my $120/year subscription.
As bonuses, I get my catalogue easily sync'd across devices, easy access to new music, and youtube ad-free.
I don't mean to discount your view, I just wanted demonstrate that there is a rationally minded market for these services.