Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by pnathan | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

pnathan

I rather liked their mayo (I grabbed it at semi-random off the shelf once).

Was saddened to hear allegations that they were doing weird buyback stuff in grocery stores.

But this isn't a red flag to me, it's the refs walking off the field. Curious how others read it.

View on HN

> it's the refs walking off the field

To stay with the sports analogy theme, doesn't that typically indicate game over?

I guess it would depend on the rules of the sport. In soccer/football, the game can't continue without the refs, but just because there are no refs doesn't mean the game is over. Sometimes they'll leave the field in protest of player or coach behavior. There's nothing a ref can do if a player refuses a penalty that was assigned to them, so they'll typically leave the field until the player accepts that he's been penalized.

So in this situation, the board leaving would be a strong indicator that they're protesting the actions of the company or of the CEO. There's nothing saying they can't come back if the situation changes, or the company can forfeit the game and then it's all over.

At least under FIFA bylaws, once a player refuses to leave the field in a timely manner it's the obligation of the Referee to gather their associates and depart the field, ending the match.

There have been at least some situations exactly like I described[1]. I'll admit I don't know all of the rules of the game so I can't describe what might have been different in this situation.

[1] https://www.si.com/planet-futbol/2016/02/21/bayer-leverkusen...

Apparently there are allegations of them selling tainted food [0]... Target removed them from their shelves last month. I'm disappointed to hear about it as they're my goto mayonnaise brand, but there are now many "eggless" alternatives on the market now.

[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-22/target-be...

they were never the refs -- CEO has controlled the board's vote since 2015

Reply on news.ycombinator.com