That's surprising. What do you perceive to be the basic premise of the Rogaway article? It's certainly not about cutesiness. "Politically superficial" is not how I'd choose to describe it.
he argues 1) cryptographers (and computer scientists in general) should be more political (good!), 2) cryptography needs a new framing (good!), 3) privacy and exception from government search is an unalloyed right (not so good), 4) better crypto will solve privacy issues (not so good).
In sum, the article does a lot of good work, and more than anything, it contains some important and refreshing rethinking of the field of crypto. This is all very important. Nonetheless, it ends up taking for granted a number of political positions that should, I think, also be contested (Rogaway takes the first step!). More crypto does not equal a better world.
I don't think "Alice" and "Bob" have really much to do with it.