Suppose I have peanuts and you have shellfish.
I don't care for peanuts (in fact, I'm allergic to them). The subjective value that I assign to them is zero (or negative)
Same thing, you don't care for shellfish (religious reasons).
Suppose we move around existing assets -- trade peanuts for shellfish.
All of a sudden both of us have something we can use, of non-zero subjective value (the only kind of value that exists, btw).
To say that no value has been created in the transaction is quite simply to ignore the basic universal motivation for trade.
Every voluntary transaction happens only because both parties believe that they're getting the better part of the deal (I'd rather have shellfish than peanuts).