One Month Without AMP
alexkras.com
alexkras.com
Make the AMP icon (or some other element) lead to the AMP page and leave the normal link as the main search result.
I hate AMP for completely practical reasons and have no issue with the ideology. It messes up my back button, the top bar is annoying, and most importantly I frequently have AMP pages fail to load with a white screen but had the normal page load. It's bad enough they're tricking me into visiting an AMP page (I've never intended to visit one), but then it's broken when the source page isn't.
Edit: I guess a larger point, if Google would penalize for size of download instead of promoting AMP, I am sure sites like BBC would work hard to shrink their mobile download size.
I still find the concept of AMP cache very troublesome, even if it was built with good intentions.
"July 14 - onward An incremental improvement in Google's logging system now provides better accounting for results in lower positions. This change might cause increase in impressions, but also a decrease in average positions. This change only affects Search Console reporting, not your actual performance on Google Search. "
> [..]
> Since not having AMP support does not result in a Google Search penalty, why bother?
Maybe it DID get penalized?
I drilled down into top 3 search terms from the last month an updated the article.
Results are:
- Git Tips – Average position declined from 2.4 to 2.9
- Angular Performance – Average position improved from 2.4 to 2.3
- Node JS Memory Leak – Average position improved from 3.4 to 2.9
Based on that, in comparison with other observations I am pretty sure that my site did not get penalized. Please let me know if you disagree or if you think I should pull some other stats.
Edit.