I too didn't have an undergrad in CS but was pretty comfortable as a web dev and sys admin. I ended up getting a MS in Computer Science which definitely took my career to the next level.
What I discovered was that while my day job had prepared me well for actually doing the work, my CS degree taugh me how to interview well and get the next role up.
What I mean is, interviewers tend to focus on many theoretical topics and are looking for the "correct" answer often..some key words that they want you to utter as part of the answer.
My CS degree taught me how to talk educated about technology, algorithms, software engineering, project management etc while my job actually taught me how to do it.