I don't envy the position of any non-technical person that has to make key technical decisions on a technical project.
Ultimately it takes a good developer to spot a good developer, so a non-technical person seeking to build a "robust web application" starts at a huge disadvantage.
Without understanding the pros and cons of each language choice, all he can do is gamble on finding a smarter person than himself that he can trust. I'm advocating he choose the anti-PHP guy, slightly tongue-in-cheek, because given the limited amount of information presented, that choice gives him the best odds.
Being in the position of having to make such a bet is less than desirable, but given his lack of technical knowledge, what else would you have him do?