Dutch Agency Admits Mistake in Climate Report
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
If not, we're exposed to selection bias.
Simply being contained in a large document is not an excuse - a review includes multiple reviewers, each checking the accuracy of parts of the document. Given enough time, the error would be found, and in fact WAS found given a little more time - that's the point of the article after all.
But when this shoddy report is published to the world, rushed and badly reviewed, it does a disservice to all of us. I hate to be the messenger, but good intentions are NOT enough to change the world.
If the most "glaring" error that the AGW "skeptics" could find after sifting through a 3,000 page report with a fine-toothed comb is a difference between "prone to flooding" and "below sea level" -- and if that error was primarily the result of faulty government data, rather than primarily the result of faulty research methods -- then that's actually indicative of a really fucking solid report.
The strategy among the "skeptics" here seems to be to find minor errors in this report, and then try to use those minor errors to cast a shadow over the rest of the report. What they don't want anybody to notice is that they aren't actually arguing with any of the conclusions of the report.
Well, fortunately, people are noticing this, and calling them out for using this ridiculous tactic.
So, go ahead and keep attacking it on those grounds, but you're not likely to convince many people here. The only thing that's being accomplished is to make the "skeptic" view look more and more absurd.
If you insinuate I am somehow trying to convince anyone that global warming is wrong, your zeal is clouding your judgement - my simple remarks were directed simply at the unfortunate fact that the report was released before a review found the errors - which was what? a matter of weeks?
I draw a parallel with your tiny grammatical error because the mistake about sea level in the Netherlands was introduced by the editing process when an early draft of the report was being condensed down to a shorter version. This is categorically different from an error in the statistical methodology or logical reasoning.
I merely expect that when "experts" communicate something that impacts a large portion of the world population, that they make damn sure of their "facts". All of them!
BTW: I never claimed to be a grammar expert. :)
"The original report said global warming will put 75 million to 250 million Africans at risk of severe water shortages in the next 10 years, but a recalculation showed that range should be 90 million to 220 million, the agency said."
So instead of it happening in 10 years, it's going to happen in 90 million years???????
I'm amazed at the amount of people that feel that this is no big deal.
My biggest problem is that entire countries are basing laws on these findings, which cost citizens billions of dollars in tax revenue. There is now too much money going around for anyone to really come out with the truth.
Even Al Gore, the visionary behind global climate change (which was global warming, but got changed for some reason........) has millions of dollars invested in green energy companies. Nobody on the left seems to see this as a conflict of interest. Al gore is creating legislation that will make him a billionaire. When there is even a hint of a republican trying to do something like this, people are up in arms.
I didn't downvote you, but only because it was already at -2 and that seemed reasonable to me. Frankly, I didn't see much in your comment that merited a response. I read it, and thought of all of the other things I ought to be doing, and couldn't justify taking the time to try to clear things up for someone who can't be arsed to clear them up for themselves. I might as well be spending my time arguing with someone proclaiming that the moon landing was a hoax.
> So instead of it happening in 10 years, it's going to happen in 90 million years???????
Your original criticism betrayed a serious bias on your part. Even now, your response to the correction is that "the numbers are still off" -- well, no. The range has been narrowed. Technically speaking, the original range is still correct. And, again, this doesn't in any way address the point of the report, which is that many millions of people -- especially the poor -- will be affected by this. Yet, in typical style, rather than addressing this point, people who have a problem with the conclusions of the report are quibbling over the details in it as though that casts some kind of shadow of a doubt over the conclusions of the report.
It does not.
You then compounded that mistake,
> Even Al Gore...
I actually smirked at this. It would have been totally hilarious, if it were part of a parody. Unfortunately you seem to be completely serious. (Or trolling successfully.)
Concern about global warming predates Mr. Gore by quite a bit. However, he's chosen to serve as a spokesperson and representative-of-sorts for the various efforts to mitigate the risks posed by anthropogenic global warming. He is a figurehead, and as such, those with an axe to grind are tilting at him instead of, say, y'know, the facts. His name was nowhere in the article, nowhere else in the comments. You introduced it.
Article: "There was an error in a report."
Comments: "This proves the report is not trustworthy." "No, it doesn't."
You: "Al Gore Al Gore Alllll Gooooooore!"
As far as "profiting" from this? This really, really isn't hard to understand. If I wanted to be a spokesperson for space exploration, then it would stand to reason that I am personally interested in space exploration, and it would further stand to reason that I would want to invest in space exploration. Conflict of interest? No, not at all. A conflict of interest only occurs when such a person is in a position to legislate or rule over other people who might disagree. i.e., Gore probably shouldn't serve on a jury against BP; or, if all of those companies were based in a particular state, and he was a representative of that state, then he might legitimately be accused of pork barrel spending if he pushed for a bill increasing funding for those companies.
But no such thing is happening. Instead you're reaching into as many ugly paint buckets as possible, and throwing wet brushes: "He's profiting from this!" "It's all his fault!" Etc.
> My biggest problem is that entire countries are basing laws on these findings, which cost citizens billions of dollars in tax revenue.
Even if I were to agree that this is true -- and I don't -- you are completely ignoring the cost of doing nothing. If it were possible to say that Hurricane Katrina occurred as a direct result of anthropogenic global warming -- which I don't believe, either, by the way -- then wouldn't that imply that the costs of global warming were at least equal to the price tag of Katrina, plus all other costs? This cannot be ignored.
And then there's the benefits from continuing to advance "green" technologies. I want to see more efficient wind farms; I want to see better solar panel technologies. These are things which move our society forward. We will not advance, technologically, into the next century, by underfunding new technologies and spending the money instead on older technologies.
> There is now too much money going around for anyone to really come out with the truth.
No, the truth is available, but some people aren't listening.
> ...which was global warming, but got changed for some reason........
This was the only part of your comment that I briefly considered responding to, and only because I see this idiotic statement way too often.
It would be totally trivial to find the answer to this. Easy. Piece-of-cake. But doing so would require you to venture outside your comfort zone, the comfort zone where you believe you already have all the information you need to make an "informed" decision.
The central issue is warming. When oceans get warmer, when surface and air temperatures get warmer, the climate changes. Thus, "global warming" -> "global climate change".
The maddeningly stupid thing about this particular red herring is that the term change was the result of uninformed people running around shrieking, "But it's colder this Winter in my town than it was last year! That means global warming is lies, all lies!"