But obviously Canonical's lawyers don't think shipping it separately is the same as shipping it in the kernel, because if they did they would not ship it separately to begin with.
If this ever goes to court it will be an interesting case.
There's legal disagreement, and saying "Ubuntu did it" doesn't make those problems disappear. (Sadly)
Hmm... not sure what you meant by this statement ?
I.e. their opinion is not the only opinion on the matter.
I -have- seen a lot of argument online, opinions and otherwise that disagree with this, but not anything from a lawyer - mainly "philosophical" or opining on the "intent" of the GPL, rather than "based on clauses x, y, and z, this is impermissible".
Which is not to say, if something of an opinion exists in response to Canonical's release of ZFS, I would love to see it - a legal opinion, not armchair lawyering or opinionizing.