LIBOR fixing is one thing. But the realization that there is no market that LIBOR measures is truly astonishing!
2021 will be an interesting year...
LIBOR fixing is one thing. But the realization that there is no market that LIBOR measures is truly astonishing!
2021 will be an interesting year...
Except that's not true. Interbank lending is still a $70 billion market in the United States alone [1]. Small compared to banks' balance sheets and less than the $500 billion from as recently as February 2008, but material nonetheless.
Good rule of thumb in finance is to ignore Matt Taibbi.
But a second problem is that the banks might not even know. Libor surveys asked banks each day what they would have to pay to borrow money unsecured from other big banks, but over time the banks sort of stopped doing that, particularly in some of the more obscure combinations of tenors and currencies that nonetheless reported Libor rates. So the banks' Libor submitters would guesstimate their submissions based on deposit rates and commercial-paper rates and secured-borrowing rates and other tenors and what brokers and their buddies were telling them.
Last I'd checked Mr. Levine was pretty well regarded.
Not that it matters... We're well into ad hominem and argument from authority territory here.
I'm not saying it is wrong because Taibbi wrote it. It's wrong because he got basic facts about interbank lending wrong, i.e. that it exists. I'm then passing along my observation that, whenever I've fact checked Taibbi, his facts have tended to be wrong.
> Matt Levine...said the exact same thing
Taibbi said there is no interbank lending. Libor is totally made up. Levine said that there is less interbank lending and so some of the numbers had to be made up some of the time. He concludes the paragraph you quote with this sentence:
"[Libor] was all more or less good enough as a casual system for resetting the rates on a few billion dollars worth of syndicated loans, but it was not accurate down to the hundredth of a basis point as a foundation for the financial system, or as the source for pricing hundreds of trillions of dollars of derivatives."
That's important context. Libor was a good enough number for a market where precision didn't matter (syndicated loans). It proceeded to be used, and abused, improperly. It's not a totally made up number like Taibbi makes it out to be. It's a totally inappropriately-used number.
TL; DR You'll walk away better informed about almost any financial topic reading Levine over Taibbi.
Ultimately the point remains: there isn't sufficient market activity to build a real value for Libor so it's basically made up from whole cloth
Your nuance, while interesting if you care to dig deeply, doesn't change the conclusion. It's a distinction without a material difference.
The least active currency-tenor, since deprecated, traded once a month. Most currency-tenors trade many, many, many times a day. There's plenty of market activity to build Libor-esque metrics.
> It's a distinction without a material difference
It's a world of material difference. The Fed Funds rate in the United States is based on the same kind of wholesale unsecured interbank lending as Libor is supposed to be. The metric, and the market it's based on, work.
We can have something like Libor based on market activity. It just won't be published every day for every tenor and currency.
If you just read Taibbi, the answer would seem to be to scrap any attempt at measuring the market because you cannot measure something that does not exist. If you understand the nuance, you walk away better appreciating what (a) went wrong, (b) we should do to improve future metrics and (c) one should look for when evaluating other metrics purporting to do similar things. You also gain an understanding for the kinds of scaling problems financial markets run into, which are quite unlike scaling problems in other contexts.
Its not Matt Taibbi but the regulators who concluded there is no basis for LIBOR as reported in the article so perhaps you meant to accuse the regulator of sensationalism.
Regulators did not conclude this. They concluded (a) better metrics for banks' costs of capital exist (e.g. the Fed funds rate [1]), (b) the market Libor is based on (wholesale unsecured interbank term lending) is too small and inactive to provide the sort of precision Libor implies and (c) transitioning from Libor will be messy [2].
[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS
[2] https://www.fca.org.uk/news/speeches/the-future-of-libor
No, there is a basis. The regulator Taibbi cites speaks competently about this [1]; the least actively-traded currency-tenor traded only about once a month. (Every other currency-tenor traded more often.)
That may be a fine frequency for 6-month wholesale interbank rates in Danish krona (which, until recent reforms, was one of the currencies Libor was quoted for [2]). But turning it into a daily rate with three decimal places of precision is silly.
[1] https://www.fca.org.uk/news/speeches/the-future-of-libor
Please read his work and make up your own mind.
The Libor fixing is real as is the FX rate fixing. Apologists for the banking system and governments often demand the the smoking gun in fraud and conspiracy even when its not always possible, unless at great personal cost like in Snowden, but here the smoking gun and entire armory is out in the open. Attempting now to discredit the messenger is disingenuous.
"It's just amazing how LIBOR fixing can make you that much money!"[1]
[1] http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2013/11/01/5-firms-21-astonishing-...
Yes. It's a subtlety bulldozed over in this article because nuance doesn't sell clicks like outrage. Recapitulating an earlier comment, the regulator Taibbi cites speaks competently about this [1]; the least actively-traded currency-tenor traded only about once a month. (Every other currency-tenor traded more often.)
That may be a fine frequency for 6-month wholesale interbank rates in Danish krona (which, until recent reforms, was one of the currencies Libor was quoted for [2]). But turning it into a daily rate with three decimal places of precision is silly.
[1] https://www.fca.org.uk/news/speeches/the-future-of-libor