http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=150070 - highly-debatable claims presented as science
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149708 - decent, but 30 points? Besides, the comments thread looks identical to something I could read on Reddit.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149467 - who cares?
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149482 - already covered at least a dozen times. I would suggest beginning with a search engine...
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149618 - ancient news
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149196 - old news
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149091 - one of the worst of hundreds of front page submissions regarding the mortgage crisis
I do understand that this is only my viewpoint and that others may have liked at least some of these submissions, but this is coming from someone who was never a member of a link aggregating site. I started reading Reddit towards the end of 2007, but that didn't last long, as I quickly tired of seeing the same headlines and C-C-C-COMBO-BREAKER!! posts, so I left.
Hacker News served its purpose for me for quite a while: giving me the ideas and motivation to create my own startup. I also like some of the interesting science and hacker-related articles. Lately, though, it just hasn't been what I've been looking for.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149482
All the rest, as far as I can tell by statistical measures, are like the stories that would have made the frontpage in the past. They also seem to me personally about the same.
Do folks not understand how teaching works? How coaching works? How leadership works? How a community works? This group isn't just a dusty library, filled with books that may be out of date and librarians who tell you to be quiet and RTFM.
People like having their questions answered by real humans. They crave contact. They crave personality. They need to know that someone is out there, listening. The voice of an actual human telling you what to do is often more real than your own voice, or the disembodied voice of an old book.
Yes, the questions are almost always the same. That's how teaching works: You're surrounded by novices, and once they stop being novices they leave and are replaced by another group of novices. The secret to being a good teacher is to take enough joy in helping others -- and, less charitably, in the sound of your own voice repeating itself -- to be able to do it again and again with only minor variations.
That said, I have seen similar Ask YC posts that do cover the exact same ground as old ones and annoy me a bit more than that one. I guess I was trying to use that one as an example of such a submission, although it wasn't really a good example.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149789
Wow. Just wow.
The worst story on the frontpage by that standard right now is
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149752
The third worst, ironically, is the one complaining about the problem:
Feature requests might work, maybe not. In any case, it would also be necessary to fairly ruthlessly kill navel-gazing articles on the front page, or at least move them to navelgazing.news.yc.com...
Why is that ironic? No solutions are presented. No value is generated. An individual starting a company or hacking on a problem does not grow as a result of having read the story. It is self-referential, self-aggrandizing, and as you point out, among the worst entries in the derby.
It sounds as if vote-weighting has a good deal of merit, based solely on the three pieces of evidence presented.
- If we can get the list of the top 10-50 hostnames (xkcd, etc) posted on reddit, and deny publication of those hostnames on HN, the signal to noise ratio should go up (how much I don't know?)
- Obviously, some good posts would be missed, but it's alright to have a few false positives, since this is a website of aggregated news and not email
What do the folks here think?
In which case, how about NOT awarding karma for posting links for those hostnames, and award karma for the comments. what do you think?