He specifically says that virtual currencies themselves are a valid reason to use the Blockchain.
He specifically says that virtual currencies themselves are a valid reason to use the Blockchain.
For his blockchain example, I couldn't find his Dutch handicap parking story via Google for more details so I don't know if a traditional central database would solve the same exact problem.
I'm saying that virtually all dismissals of a blockchain in favor of central databases almost always removes the benefits of decentralization. The ironic part is that the skeptics don't realize that the central db "solution" is incomplete when compared to all the decentralized goals (e.g. multiple witnesses guarding against tampering, potentially lower cost ownership verification, etc). Yes, if one changes the rules or moves the goal posts around, one can replace a decentralized blockchain with MySQL. If somebody is the skeptic, does he even notice that he performed that sleight-of-hand in his argument?!?
There should be nothing wrong in moving the goal posts, when the original goal seems to be the wrong one.
The innovation brought by the Blockchain was using a proof-of-work to achieve consensus and avoid double-spending in a network of semi-anonymous peers.
The vast majority of proposed uses of the Blockchain for non-currency reasons that I've seen do not suffer from this problem, and therefore do not need the innovation brought by it.
Then we've been exposed to different examples. I've not seen any non-trivial proposed uses for distributed consensus blockchain that can be exactly replaced by a central db. Replacement always involves relaxing a constraint (e.g. trust the centralized organization not to tamper, etc).
shandor's point can be generalized to "solutions looking for a problem" which I already agreed with. Where I differ is based on the actual debates on the serious uses of blockchain I've seen, I don't see that technology abuse as the overwhelming situation.
But I'm not talking about any distributed data sharing such as p2p bittorrent with hash verification, or git/github, or NNTP Usenet, or the distributed accounting system you worked on, etc. For purposes of this thread, "blockchain" is synonymous with decentralized trust which I believe is how it's usually used.
I can agree that blockchain didn't invent "decentralized data sharing" but that's not relevant to my point.
Maybe the "exact same problem" is the wrong thing to try to solve? It might not be a problem in the first place (by itself), just a re-formulation of the actual problem so that it's solvable by blockchain, which seems to be the author's point.